Guest Reviews
Yelp Reviews
"Definitely our favorite place to eat in Harbor Country. We have been there multiple times since their relocation and have brought out of town guests. We have never been disappointed and have heard no complaints..." -Buckeye D.
"Tonight at Timothy's was everything you could wish for in a dining experience. Ann's recommendations on drinks were in-depth and thoughtful based on our preferences. The cucumber basil martini was crisp and refreshing and the new old fashion was a great take on a classic. The shining star is the owner, Tim. He's the textbook definition of hospitable, so gracious and so generous. The different sections of the restaurant have different feels so Timothy's is perfect for a casual drink in the bar or a romantic date night. I love the TVs in the floor of the bar, what an interesting touch! Timothy's will always have my business. "-Madeline Z.
“Amazing restaurant with original and creative twists. We have been coming here very often for years and the food and service simply continue to improve. Tim is the chef-owner who has a great attention to detail and puts out some top-quality offerings. The cocktails and off-peak specials are wonderful too.” - Julie H.
“The Go to Restaurant for dining in Harbor Country. Creative menu, picturesque setting, dining at bar or main room all appeal to those who are looking for something out of the ordinary.” - Rickie H.
“My absolutely favorite seafood restaurant! Wish it was closer to home! Wonderful presentation and robust flavors in every dish.” - Kip K.
“My husband & I went to Timothy's unaware we'd have the best local meal EVER! We could taste the freshness of the coconut macadamia grouper & walleye with a gorgeous presentation. We were informed the fish is flown in fresh daily. Our server was attentive & knowledgable. An absolutely stellar unique 5 star dining experience.” - Wendy B.
“What a nice place. Good food. Nice staff. Reasonable prices. We had heard about Timothy's from friends who live in the area. They said it was the best place for dinner in the area. We're happy we tried it. We will absolutely go back.” - Greg M.
"Every bite is amazing. The tasteful blend of American and Asian flavors would succeed even in the hippest neighborhoods of New York City. The signature Timothy's salad and coconut macadamia nut crusted grouper are dynamite. Expect to see Timothy's food on the Zagat and Michelin guides soon.” - David H.
Click here for more Yelp Reviews: Timothy's Restaurant Reviews on Yelp
Google Reviews
"We just had a delicious meal with a large group. The restaurant was very busy but I didn't see anyone having to wait to be seated. The wait staff were great! Even though we were in a large group the ladies were very attentive and efficient. Great prices on meals. We'll be back for the specials!" -Amy H-R
"Beautiful rooms and perfect service is how I would describe Timothy’s. We took our time to try it because aim the only fish eater in the family, but once we looked at the menu everyone in my family found multiple things to eat. They offer 12 items for $12 and each one is a full entre. Best New England Chowder I have ever had!" -Nick P.
“Overall this is about the best restaurant in the area. I live nearby so come here all the time. Service and food is always on point. Their 12 for $12 menu during the week is great, you won't find a better deal anywhere. The Timothy's Salad and tomato soup are two other highlights, definitely give them a try. Like any place here it gets slammed on weekends and can be a pain to get in. They're pretty big though so just come in after the 8:00 rush and you'll be fine.” - Chris E.
“You can never go wrong at Timothy's. Great food, service and atmosphere. A true gem in Southwest Michigan.” - Mike N
“Excellent dining experience! Beautiful environment for dinner and drinks. Fun knowledgeable staff makes an evening out something to remember and enjoy. The food is first rate. You will not be disappointed with all the wonderful choices the menu has to offer.” - Frank P
“The staff and chef were wonderful. The chef made a vegetarian dish for my mom and she loved it. Thank you Timothy's for the wonderful experience. We will come again and tell others about the excellent food and service.” - Drake
“Wonderful food and selection. Fresh and unique. A MUST on your visit to the area!” - Jaye M
“Love this place. Fresh innovative and delicious. Service always helpful and glad you are there.” - Pete P
Click here for more Google Reviews: Timothy's Restaurant Reviews on Google
“Always consistent and great. Probably the most inventive food in the area. Chef Tim is always there and often delivers the meals himself! Stylish interior · Farm-to-table · Great food · Large menu · Hip atmosphere · Classic cocktails · Creative cuisine.” - Justin H
“Great atmosphere awesome service tonight’s 12 dollar menu was OUTSTANDING as usual!!” - Tim S
“One of my absolute favorite places! The food is amazing! From the one of a kind appetizers to the dinners and all the fabulous specials! The cocktails are great and very different! Worth the drive, no matter where you’re coming from! Never been disappointed!” - Stylish interior · Daily specials · Scenic views · Cosy atmosphere · Great food · Outdoor dining · Tasting menus · Classic cocktails · Romantic atmosphere · Hip atmosphere · Fine dining · Creative cuisine. - Deena E
“What a fantastic experience!!! The food, the staff and what a beautiful restaurant!!! We will be back!!!” - Joanne M
“Just a wonder experience and we had the best person taking care of us. Highly recommended!!! Great food · Creative cuisine · Cosy atmosphere · Large menu · Stylish interior · Romantic atmosphere · Scenic views” - Angie A
“Always a wonderful experience! The drinks and dining are fabulous and Anthony always makes us feel right at home!” - Amber W
“Friendly attentive staff, good job Randy. Calming live music, it does not disturb the dinner conversation. The food tastes great, and has beautiful presentation. The decor is classy, unique, and supports local artists. Great cocktail menu. Great food · Stylish interior · Creative cuisine” Anne A
“Even though it was the hottest day of the year, it was still very cool sitting in Jake’s backyard and Jake’s pizza shack. The pizza crust was very thin and very nice. The different types of pizzas were marinara, margarita, potato and mushroom. All of them were extremely delicious! You must give it a try!” - Ann H
“Phenomenal food and service!!!!! Love it!!! Creative cuisine · Hip atmosphere · Healthy options · Fine dining · Large menu” Sara D
“This was an amazing culinary experience!!! I would highly recommend this venue!!” - Donna K
Click here for more Facebook Reviews: Timothy's Restaurant Reviews on Facebook
Trip Advisor
"We have dined here several times and thoroughly enjoyed it every single time. I have loved everything I have ever ordered, and I've tasted my spouses and friends too. Excellent. Timothy even comes out of the kitchen and visits with his patrons. LOVE TIMOTHYS" -Jenni B.
"Excellent food, the service is friendly and very good. The restaurant has several rooms and is much larger than it seems, which is good as they can be very busy. Fine dining with great and reasonably priced specials. We had mussels over spaghetti, outstanding, and grilled salmon, again excellent. Salad dressings and everything is house made and very special." -R Bruce D
“We found this restaurant on trip advisor and decided to try it. We made a reservation for 6:30. (I’d suggest making a reservation.). We were warmly greeted and seated promptly. The food is excellent. My husband had clam chowder and the lamb. He raves about the flavor of the lamb. I had the roasted tomato bisque (wow) and the Asian spring rolls as my entree. The service is excellent. Our waitress was busy but checked on us regularly. We will be back this summer and we’re bringing our friends with us. Such a pleasant evening.” – Bud L
“Fantastic service and delicious food. I took my friend here for her birthday. She had been here many times but it was my first time. We were greeted and seated immediately right by the fireplace which was super cozy on a brisk late winter day. Our server was right to our table helping us with special information and assisting my friend to find a drink she would enjoy. Our server was on the ball, bringing us our drinks, soup and salad and bread. Everything that was to be hot was hot and cold was cold. They even chilled the fork that came with my friend's salad. It's the little things, attention to detail, that set this place apart. My friend got the pork chop dinner off the $12 menu, I chose the bacon & onion crusted walleye special and both were absolutely delicious. Her asparagus was the perfect al dente, my fish was phenomenal and the arugula salad it was rested upon was the perfect complement. No dessert, we were both beyond stuffed. They allowed us to sit at the table and catch up, though we offered to move if they needed the table. It's a beautiful dining room, the bar area looks very cozy and comfortable, I will definitely return with my husband for my next visit. Delicious, fantastic service and a wonderful atmosphere. A true gem along the Red Arrow Highway.” - Elizabeth S
“Excellent food, the service is friendly and very good. The restaurant has several rooms and is much larger than it seems, which is good as they can be very busy. Fine dining with great and reasonably priced specials. We had mussels over spaghetti, outstanding, and grilled salmon, again excellent. Salad dressings and everything is house-made and very special.” - Bruce D
Click here for more Trip Advisor: Timothy's Restaurant Reviews on Trip Advisor